Taxable KISS beat a VAMS-only version of main KISS after tax over January 2, 2020–September 4, 2026. It did not win on every risk measure. VAMS-only had the shallower drawdown, and under a loss-netting tax convention the two Sortino ratios were effectively tied.
The comparison asks a narrow question: what happens if an investor follows the main KISS portfolio’s VAMS asset signals but drops the top-down macro overlay? The answer is not a simpler, more tax-efficient version of KISS. VAMS-only traded far more, realized much larger short-term gains and finished with less after-tax wealth.
The two portfolios
Both accounts began with $100,000 and used the same 60% stocks / 30% gold / 10% bitcoin strategic mix. They used the same prices, cash-yield series, distributions, transaction-cost assumption and tax-lot engine.
- Taxable KISS 5.3: the current per-asset stock and bitcoin rules, plus the annual bitcoin concentration review.
- VAMS-only: main KISS VAMS signals applied to fixed 60/30/10 caps, with the top-down regime target removed. It kept the same two-stage confirmation and whole-portfolio rebalance convention as main KISS.
- Main KISS with top-down: a diagnostic arm using the same VAMS path and frozen macro-regime history. It separates the overlay’s effect from the Taxable KISS implementation.
The primary tax convention used explicit lots and constant illustrative federal rates: 35% on short-term gains, interest and non-qualified distributions; 15% on long-term gains and qualified dividends; and 15% on long-term gold gains as specified for this study. The base case gave no credit for realized losses. A separate scenario added annual netting and loss carryforward.
Main results
“Ongoing” CAGR deducts taxes already paid but leaves unrealized gains untaxed. “Liquidated” CAGR also pays the modeled tax on selling everything at the end.
| Metric, primary convention | Taxable KISS | VAMS only | Main KISS with top-down |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ongoing after-tax CAGR | 16.29% | 10.25% | 9.11% |
| Liquidated after-tax CAGR | 14.96% | 9.96% | 8.97% |
| Sortino, CAGR / downside deviation | 1.56 | 1.33 | 1.33 |
| Maximum drawdown | −22.95% | −17.63% | −13.91% |
| Annualized volatility | 14.64% | 10.72% | 9.49% |
| Liquidated wealth | $253,511 | $188,429 | $177,397 |
| Modeled taxes, including liquidation | $30,969 | $42,147 | $43,818 |
| Gross annual turnover | 32.1% | 335.9% | 460.1% |
Taxable KISS delivered about five percentage points more liquidated CAGR, but with a deeper worst decline and higher volatility. The tradeoff is not a free lunch.
Loss netting narrows the gap
The primary no-loss-credit convention is intentionally conservative and carried over from the September 8 after-tax study. Because VAMS-only realized substantial losses as well as gains, that convention can penalize it disproportionately.
The netting scenario allowed annual settlement by tax character, excess long-term losses to offset short-term gains, and unused losses to carry forward without refunds.
| Metric, annual netting | Taxable KISS | VAMS only | Main KISS with top-down |
|---|---|---|---|
| Liquidated after-tax CAGR | 15.07% | 11.62% | 10.45% |
| Sortino, CAGR / downside deviation | 1.57 | 1.56 | 1.55 |
| Maximum drawdown | −22.95% | −16.35% | −11.79% |
| Annualized volatility | 14.63% | 10.70% | 9.48% |
The liquidated-CAGR advantage remains 3.45 percentage points, but the risk-adjusted result is a near tie. An investor who weights drawdown more heavily than after-tax growth could reasonably prefer the VAMS-only path.
Taxes amplified the gap, but did not create it
VAMS-only paid $24,397 of modeled short-term tax before liquidation, versus $815 for Taxable KISS. Its 335.9% annual gross turnover also generated more trading costs and more realized gains.
With zero taxes, Taxable KISS still led: 17.35% versus 14.74% liquidated CAGR. Tax drag was 2.39 percentage points for Taxable KISS and 4.78 points for VAMS-only. Frequent VAMS rebalancing made the tax code expensive; it did not manufacture the entire difference.
Exposure explains more. Taxable KISS averaged 44.1% stocks, 28.7% gold, 10.1% bitcoin and 17.1% cash. VAMS-only averaged 43.2% stocks, 19.4% gold, 5.6% bitcoin and 31.8% cash. The VAMS-only arm carried less gold and bitcoin and more cash.
What removing top-down did
The top-down diagnostic is the cleanest part of the study. Within the same VAMS implementation, removing the macro overlay raised liquidated CAGR from 8.97% to 9.96%, but deepened maximum drawdown from −13.91% to −17.63% and raised volatility from 9.49% to 10.72%.
That is a risk-return trade, not a free improvement. The top-down overlay reduced return and reduced risk in this sample. It did not make VAMS-only competitive with Taxable KISS on after-tax wealth.
The result was stable across the checks
Taxable KISS led VAMS-only on liquidated CAGR in every fresh-account start year:
| Start year | Taxable KISS | VAMS only | Main KISS with top-down |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2020 | 14.96% | 9.96% | 8.97% |
| 2021 | 12.99% | 7.91% | 7.17% |
| 2022 | 13.81% | 9.13% | 8.52% |
| 2023 | 20.92% | 13.77% | 11.56% |
Those are overlapping windows, not independent trials. They show the ranking was not confined to one start date in this sample.
The ranking also survived zero tax, a 28% long-term gold rate, 25 basis points per trade, one additional close of execution delay and FIFO lot selection. The size of the advantage changed; the direction did not.
| Sensitivity | Taxable KISS liquidated CAGR | VAMS-only liquidated CAGR |
|---|---|---|
| Primary, 35%/15%, 10 bp | 14.96% | 9.96% |
| Annual netting | 15.07% | 11.62% |
| Zero tax | 17.35% | 14.74% |
| 28% long-term gold | 14.46% | 9.57% |
| 25 bp per trade | 14.88% | 9.45% |
| One extra close of delay | 15.14% | 10.32% |
| FIFO lot selection | 14.96% | 9.48% |
A paired 63-session block bootstrap of daily after-tax returns produced a VAMS-only minus Taxable KISS annualized arithmetic mean difference of −5.86 percentage points, with a 95% interval of −11.07 to −0.76. That is not a CAGR confidence interval, a drawdown confidence interval or out-of-sample evidence.
What this does and does not establish
The study supports keeping Taxable KISS rather than replacing it with VAMS-only without top-down. It does not establish that Taxable KISS is universally superior. VAMS-only had materially lower volatility and a shallower drawdown, and under annual loss netting its Sortino ratio matched Taxable KISS.
The comparison also is not a pure test of the top-down overlay. Taxable KISS and VAMS-only differ in allocation logic, rebalance mechanics and turnover. The diagnostic arm separates some of that difference, but the primary comparison remains a comparison of two portfolio implementations.
Finally, the sample is retrospective and already inspected. It uses current-vintage adjusted prices, constant illustrative tax rates and a bitcoin daily-close proxy. It excludes state taxes, NIIT, wash-sale adjudication and a complete Schedule D calculation. Main KISS with top-down uses current KISS 2.5 VAMS with the frozen regime path; it is a diagnostic reconstruction, not a production-parity claim for the saved KISS 2.4 snapshot.
The full experiment register, results, daily after-tax values, lot-level trades and sensitivities are recorded in the research results file. The after-tax method follows the earlier Taxable KISS after-tax review, which reached a similar conclusion about implementation and measurement: tax-aware portfolios must be judged on after-liquidation wealth, risk and exposure together, not on trading frequency alone.
